Olive Oatman: The True Story of the Woman With the Blue Tattoo

Olive Oatman: The True Story of the Woman With the Blue Tattoo
Olive Oatman was a white pioneer girl who survived an attack on her family in Arizona in 1851, lived about five years with Native people along the Colorado River, and came home in 1856 with a blue tattoo across her chin. The tattoo made her famous. A bestselling book and years of paid lectures told America it was the mark of a slave. The Mohave people who gave it to her, and the historians who have listened to them since, tell a different story. Below is her whole life, how the tattoo was made and what it meant to the Mohave. We also get into why historians still argue over whether she was a captive or a daughter.

Who was Olive Oatman?

Olive Oatman (1837 to 1903) was the second of seven children of Royce and Mary Ann Oatman. She is remembered as the first known white American woman with a traditional Native facial tattoo, and as the subject of one of the most read captivity stories of the 19th century.

Olive Oatman's story in short

In February 1851 her family was attacked on the Gila River trail in what is now southern Arizona. Her parents and four of her siblings were killed. Her brother Lorenzo, 15, was beaten and left for dead but lived. Olive, 13, and her sister Mary Ann, 7, were taken. They spent about a year with the Yavapai, then were traded to the Mohave, who live along the Colorado River. Mary Ann died there during a famine. In 1856 Olive was brought to Fort Yuma, and soon after a minister turned her story into a book that sold tens of thousands of copies.

Most sources say she was 13 when she was taken. Wikipedia says 14. She was born on September 7, 1837, so in February 1851 she was 13.

Olive Ann Oatman's early life and the journey west

Olive Ann Oatman was born in La Harpe, Hancock County, Illinois. Her parents left the Methodist church for the Latter Day Saints in the 1830s, and after Joseph Smith was killed in 1844 they followed a small splinter group, the Brewsterites, led by James C. Brewster. Brewster taught that the true gathering place was not Utah but the land where the Gila meets the Colorado, near today's Yuma.

In August 1850 a party of about 90 Brewsterites left Independence, Missouri, in wagons. The group split in New Mexico. Royce Oatman led the southern branch through Socorro and Tucson, and at Maricopa Wells, in the Pima villages, the other families decided to stay. The Oatmans went on alone with one wagon: two parents, seven children aged 1 to 17, and a mother who was eight months pregnant.

What happened to the Oatman family in 1851?

In 1851 a group of Native men, almost certainly Western Yavapai, attacked the Oatman wagon on the Gila River about 80 to 90 miles east of Yuma. Six members of the family died. Lorenzo survived. Olive and Mary Ann were taken alive.

The attack on the Gila trail

The family was climbing a rocky grade above the river when a group of men approached and asked for food. The attack followed soon after. Royce, Mary Ann and four children were killed. Lorenzo was clubbed, thrown over the edge of the grade and left for dead. He came to and made his way back toward the Pima villages for help.

Olive's account, written up by Royce Stratton in 1857, calls the attackers Apaches. Historians today mostly identify them as Yavapai, a people Anglo travelers often lumped together with Apaches. The Sharlot Hall Museum in Prescott gives a clear short account of the attack and what came after.

Why the date of the attack is disputed

The date depends on who you read. The Yuma County marker at the site and Wikipedia say February 18, 1851. The Sharlot Hall Museum says late February. Encyclopedia.com says March 18, and Stratton's own book mentions the eighteenth of March for the family's arrival on the Gila. The site itself, near Dateland, Arizona, is marked with a sign and a pile of stones over the grave.

A year with the Yavapai

The sisters were walked north to a Yavapai camp, where they spent about a year doing hard work and, by their own account, were treated badly. Then the Mohave traded for them. Sources list the price as horses, blankets, vegetables and beads, and the sisters went north with their new hosts to the Mohave Valley.

Olive Oatman was a white pioneer girl who survived an attack on her family in Arizona in 1851, lived about five years with Native people along the Colorado River, and came home in 1856 with a blue tattoo across her chin. The tattoo made her famous. A bestselling book and years of paid lectures told America it was the mark of a slave. The Mohave people who gave it to her, and the historians who have listened to them since, tell a different story. Below is her whole life, how the tattoo was made and what it meant to the Mohave. We also get into why historians still argue over whether she was a captive or a daughter.

How Olive Oatman came to live with the Mohave

Olive Oatman came to the Mohave in 1852 through a trade pushed by a woman named Topeka, the daughter of a Mohave leader. For the next four years the sisters lived with Topeka's family, farmed with them and took part in village life.

Who the Aha Makhav are

The Mohave call themselves Aha Makhav, "people by the river" (the National Park Service spells it Aha Macav). They lived, and still live, along the Colorado River where Arizona, California and Nevada meet. In the 1850s they farmed the floodplain, planting crops such as corn and beans in the mud left when the river went down each year. Their descendants today belong to the Fort Mojave Indian Tribe and the Colorado River Indian Tribes.

Topeka, Aespaneo and the family that took the sisters in

Topeka was the daughter of a leader whose name appears as Espaniole or Espanesay depending on the source. She pushed for the trade, and the sisters lived with her family. Topeka's mother, Aespaneo, is the woman Olive later credited with saving her life.

The family gave the girls land to farm and a clan name, Oach, and Olive got a nickname, Spantsa. These are things a household does for its own children. They are also why historians argue about the word "captive", which we'll come back to.

The famine and the death of Mary Ann

Around 1855 the river failed to flood properly and the valley went hungry. Mary Ann Oatman died, most likely of starvation. Olive nearly died too, and in later accounts she said Aespaneo kept her alive by feeding her a gruel made from what little the family had left.

Olive Oatman: The True Story of the Woman With the Blue Tattoo
Olive Oatman: The True Story of the Woman With the Blue Tattoo
Olive Oatman: The True Story of the Woman With the Blue Tattoo
Olive Oatman was a white pioneer girl who survived an attack on her family in Arizona in 1851, lived about five years with Native people along the Colorado River, and came home in 1856 with a blue tattoo across her chin. The tattoo made her famous. A bestselling book and years of paid lectures told America it was the mark of a slave. The Mohave people who gave it to her, and the historians who have listened to them since, tell a different story. Below is her whole life, how the tattoo was made and what it meant to the Mohave. We also get into why historians still argue over whether she was a captive or a daughter.

Olive Oatman's tattoo meaning

Olive Oatman's tattoo was a traditional Mohave chin tattoo, given to her and to Mary Ann while they lived with the tribe. In Mohave belief, tattoos like it let a person be recognized by their ancestors in the land of the dead. Olive later told audiences it marked her as a captive. Most of the argument about her comes down to which of those you believe.

What the Olive Oatman tattoo looked like

Photographs from the 1850s and 1860s show a block of vertical lines running from just under her lower lip to the bottom of her chin, with shorter marks at each side. The lines read blue-black. You can see it clearly in the Benjamin Powelson portrait from about 1863, now in the Smithsonian's National Portrait Gallery, and in the 1857 tintype held by Yale's Beinecke Library.

We know how it was made from Olive's own description in Stratton's book. The Mohave pricked small regular rows into the skin of the chin with a sharp stick until it bled. They dipped the stick in the juice of a plant from the riverbank, then in a powder made from a blue stone found in the riverbed, which they first burned until it crumbled and turned nearly black, and pricked the powder into the wounds. Stratton gives the Mohave word as "Ki-e-chook". For anyone who tattoos, that is hand poke in its oldest form: a sharp point, a carbon pigment and a steady hand, with no machine.

Why Mohave women wore chin tattoos

Most Mohave women of that time had chin tattoos, and many men had facial marks too. Photographs taken around 1900 by C.C. Pierce and Edward Curtis show Mohave women with lines on the chin very like Olive's. The marks were part of becoming an adult member of the tribe, and the NPS describes tattooing as an important part of Mohave culture.

One thing matters a lot for Olive's story. According to Mifflin and to accounts of Mohave custom summarized on Wikipedia, the Mohave tattooed their own people. They did not mark slaves or prisoners. That is the main reason modern historians doubt the slave reading.

Recognition in the land of the dead

The Mohave believed that after death a person went to a land of the dead, and that the tattoo let the ancestors know them there. The Tattoo Archive summarizes this from an anthropologist's 1947 study, and the idea comes up in nearly every serious account. Seen that way, tattooing two girls was less like branding property and more like making sure they would end up in the right place when they died.

Olive Oatman was a white pioneer girl who survived an attack on her family in Arizona in 1851, lived about five years with Native people along the Colorado River, and came home in 1856 with a blue tattoo across her chin. The tattoo made her famous. A bestselling book and years of paid lectures told America it was the mark of a slave. The Mohave people who gave it to her, and the historians who have listened to them since, tell a different story. Below is her whole life, how the tattoo was made and what it meant to the Mohave. We also get into why historians still argue over whether she was a captive or a daughter.

Was Olive Oatman a captive or a member of the family?

Nobody can say for sure. Olive's own published account says the Mohave held her against her will and tattooed her so she could be found if she ran. Her biographer Margot Mifflin and most recent historians argue that, at least among the Mohave, she lived more like an adopted daughter. The evidence points both ways, and Olive never told the whole story in her own words.

What Stratton's book claimed

In Life Among the Indians, published in 1857 and soon retitled Captivity of the Oatman Girls, the Methodist minister Royal B. Stratton has Olive say the Mohave told the sisters that "as we belonged to them" they should wear the tattoo. The book says it was "the same with which they marked all their own captives". You can read the whole text free on Project Gutenberg. It's a vivid read. It was also written to sell. Stratton framed the Native people in it as savages and Olive as a Christian survivor, which is what his readers in 1857 wanted.

What Margot Mifflin argues in The Blue Tattoo

Margot Mifflin's biography The Blue Tattoo: The Life of Olive Oatman (University of Nebraska Press, 2009) is the most complete modern study. Her case rests on details Stratton left in without seeming to notice: the clan name, the land, the fact that Olive was never guarded, the famine food Aespaneo gave her, and the Mohave custom of tattooing only their own. Mifflin reads the tattoo as a mark of belonging.

Why the question is still open

Not everyone accepts Mifflin's reading. A review on Origins, Ohio State University's history site, questions parts of her reading, and some of her conclusions rest on reading between Stratton's lines. No Mohave account from the time survives in writing, and we could not find a source from the Fort Mojave or Colorado River tribes on Olive in particular. Olive herself was a teenager who had watched her family killed, depended on her hosts to eat, and then returned to a white world that would have shunned her for liking them. Each of those things could shape what she said, in either direction.

How Olive Oatman returned in 1856

Olive returned in February 1856, when a Yuma messenger named Francisco brought her down the Colorado to Fort Yuma after the U.S. Army sent word that it wanted her back. She was 18.

Lorenzo's five year search

Lorenzo Oatman never accepted that his sisters were dead. For about five years he kept asking officials and anyone who might listen for help finding them. His persistence is a large part of why the Army finally acted.

Francisco, the Yuma messenger and the 20 day trip

Rumors of a white woman living with the Mohave reached Fort Yuma in early 1856. Francisco, a Yuma (Quechan) man, carried trade goods up the river along with a message that the Army wanted her released. The Mohave debated it, and in the end agreed. Topeka travelled with Olive on the roughly 20 day trip down to the fort. Soon after, Lorenzo came to Fort Yuma and the two met again for the first time since the attack.

Olive Oatman was a white pioneer girl who survived an attack on her family in Arizona in 1851, lived about five years with Native people along the Colorado River, and came home in 1856 with a blue tattoo across her chin. The tattoo made her famous. A bestselling book and years of paid lectures told America it was the mark of a slave. The Mohave people who gave it to her, and the historians who have listened to them since, tell a different story. Below is her whole life, how the tattoo was made and what it meant to the Mohave. We also get into why historians still argue over whether she was a captive or a daughter.
No items found.
Olive Oatman was a white pioneer girl who survived an attack on her family in Arizona in 1851, lived about five years with Native people along the Colorado River, and came home in 1856 with a blue tattoo across her chin. The tattoo made her famous. A bestselling book and years of paid lectures told America it was the mark of a slave. The Mohave people who gave it to her, and the historians who have listened to them since, tell a different story. Below is her whole life, how the tattoo was made and what it meant to the Mohave. We also get into why historians still argue over whether she was a captive or a daughter.

The Olive Oatman book and the lecture tours

The Olive Oatman book is Royal B. Stratton's Life Among the Indians (1857), later sold as Captivity of the Oatman Girls. It went through several editions, and a British Library copy is labeled "Twenty-fifth thousand", so it sold at least 25,000 copies. Wikipedia puts the total at about 30,000.

Royal Stratton and the 1857 bestseller

Stratton was a minister who met the Oatman siblings in Oregon, where they had gone to live with relatives. He wrote the book from interviews, much of it in the first person in Olive's voice, and used part of the proceeds to send the siblings to the University of the Pacific in California.

Selling the tattoo to lecture audiences

From around 1859 Olive toured with Stratton, speaking in churches and halls across the Northeast and Midwest. The tattoo was the draw. People paid to see the face from the book's frontispiece, and the slave story was what they heard.

Meeting Irataba in New York in 1864

In 1864 the Mohave leader Irataba visited the East Coast. Olive met him in New York, and they talked in the Mohave language, which she had not forgotten. It is one of the few scenes we have of Olive and the Mohave after she left, and it does not sound like a meeting between a former slave and her owner.

Olive Oatman in old age

Olive Oatman spent her last three decades as Olive Fairchild, the wife of a banker in Sherman, Texas. She stopped lecturing, did charity work, and by most accounts covered her tattoo when she went out.

Olive Oatman's husband

Olive married John Brant Fairchild, a rancher, on November 9, 1865, in Rochester, New York. They had met at one of her lectures in Michigan. Fairchild's own brother had been killed by Native men on a cattle drive in Arizona in 1854. After the wedding she gave up public speaking. Around 1872 the couple moved to Sherman, Texas, where Fairchild founded City Bank, and they adopted a daughter, Mary Elizabeth, called Mamie. Olive is said to have worn a veil when she went out. Mental Floss, drawing on her letters, describes decades of depression and headaches.

How did Olive Oatman die?

Olive Oatman Fairchild died of a heart attack in Sherman, Texas, in March 1903, at 65. The day is given as March 20 in most accounts and March 21 in some. She is buried in West Hill Cemetery in Sherman under a stone that reads "Olive A. Oatman, wife of J.B. Fairchild". Lorenzo had died two years before her, in 1901.

Is there an Olive Oatman movie?

There is no major feature film about Olive Oatman. Her story was dramatized in a 1965 episode of the TV western Death Valley Days, "The Lawless Have Laws", with Ronald Reagan as an Army colonel. The AMC series Hell on Wheels (2011 to 2016) has a character, Eva, played by Robin McLeavy, who is loosely based on her, chin tattoo included. She also turns up in novels, including Wendy Lawton's Ransom's Mark (2003), and in place names: Oatman, Arizona, is named after the family.

What Olive Oatman's tattoo means to tattooers today

We think a tattoo's meaning belongs first to the people who make it, and Olive's life shows what happens when it doesn't. The Mohave lines on her chin were sold to a paying audience as a story about savagery, and it took more than a century for the Mohave reading to be heard. The same thing happens on a smaller scale whenever a traditional mark is copied without knowing what it means. Mohave chin tattoos belong to the Mohave. We wouldn't copy them, and we'd steer anyone who asked toward something of their own.

What we can take from her is the craft. A few straight lines, put in by hand, that tell the right people who you are. If that speaks to you, our artists work in hand poke, fine line and blackwork tattoo styles, and the history of tattoos is full of stories like this one. For more on why people have always marked their skin, read our piece on why people get tattoos. When you're ready, book a tattoo at Monolith Studio, a contemporary tattoo studio at 77 Washington Avenue, Brooklyn, NYC.

Olive Oatman FAQ

Why did Olive Oatman have a tattoo on her chin?

The Mohave gave Olive and her sister chin tattoos while the girls lived with them in the 1850s. Most Mohave women wore chin lines, and the tattoo was believed to let a person be recognized by their ancestors after death. Olive later told audiences it was a captive's mark, a reading historians now doubt.

What did Olive Oatman's tattoo mean?

To the Mohave, a chin tattoo marked someone as one of their own and let the ancestors recognize them in the land of the dead. Royal Stratton's 1857 book presented it as a mark of captivity. Biographer Margot Mifflin argues it was a sign of belonging, since the Mohave did not tattoo slaves.

Was Olive Oatman really a captive of the Mohave?

It is still debated. She was bought from the Yavapai and could not simply walk home, but the Mohave gave her land, a clan name and food during a famine, and she was not guarded. Many historians now see her as closer to an adopted daughter, though no one can say how free she felt.

How old was Olive Oatman when she was taken?

Olive Oatman was 13 when her family was attacked in February 1851. She was born on September 7, 1837, in La Harpe, Illinois. Some sources, including Wikipedia, say 14. She spent about a year with the Yavapai and four with the Mohave, and came back in 1856 at 18.

Who wrote the book about Olive Oatman?

The first book was written by Royal B. Stratton, a minister, from interviews with Olive and her brother Lorenzo. It came out in 1857 as Life Among the Indians and was later sold as Captivity of the Oatman Girls. The main modern biography is Margot Mifflin's The Blue Tattoo, published in 2009.

Is The Blue Tattoo a true story?

Yes. The Blue Tattoo: The Life of Olive Oatman by Margot Mifflin is a nonfiction biography published by the University of Nebraska Press in 2009. It is based on Stratton's book, letters, newspapers and Mohave ethnography. Some reviewers think parts of its picture of Olive's life with the Mohave go beyond the evidence.

Image credits: Olive Oatman, albumen print by Benjamin F. Powelson, c. 1863, National Portrait Gallery, Smithsonian Institution (public domain). Oatman massacre site near Dateland, Arizona, photo by Marine 69-71, CC BY-SA 4.0. Map from R.B. Stratton, Captivity of the Oatman Girls, 1857, scan University of California Libraries. Dead Mountain, Mojave Valley, lithograph by J.J. Young after H.B. Möllhausen, 1861. Mohave home going up at Parker, Arizona, c. 1900, and Mohave woman with chin tattoo, c. 1900 (not Olive), photos by C.C. Pierce, USC Digital Library. Olive Oatman, tintype, 1857, Beinecke Rare Book and Manuscript Library, Yale University. Title page of Captivity of the Oatman Girls, 1857.

No items found.
book
experience
book
experience

Monolith Studio

77 Washington Avenue, Brooklyn,
NYC, USA,11205
Monolith Studio location in NYCMonolith Studio Brooklyn, NYC, Google Map